• Mail
• Print

Christmas Fudge: The Sweetest 10-Minute Tradition

Because around here, it’s not Christmas until the fudge is made, cooled, hidden, and half-eaten before Christmas Eve.

Every family has that one holiday tradition—the thing that says, “Okay, now it’s really Christmas.”

For some, it’s matching jammies. For others, it’s caroling or decorating cookies.

But for me? It’s fudge. 🍫

That creamy, dreamy, melt-in-your-mouth chocolate slab that shows up on the counter sometime in December like a holiday beacon. Growing up, the smell alone could make me drop whatever I was doing, float into the kitchen like a cartoon character, and pray that nobody caught me cutting off a tiny sliver from the edge.

Let’s be honest—I could eat my weight in fudge. And I’m pretty sure, as a kid, I did.

Let’s Set the Scene: The OG Fudge Kitchen

It all started in my grandmother’s avocado green kitchen. 🥑 The counters were always full of holiday delicious chaos—flour dusted across every surface, pie crusts resting in windowsills, and a pan of fudge cooling in a corner under strict surveillance.

There was this one dented saucepan, probably older than me, and it was the only one she ever used for fudge. She’d stand over the stove in her apron, wooden spoon in one hand, shooing away grandkids with the other.

“Out of the kitchen unless you’re stirring!” she’d bark—half-heartedly, of course. She secretly loved having us underfoot.

And that fudge? It wasn’t just dessert. It was Christmas.

When the Fudge Gets Made, Christmas Gets Real

Even now, all these years later, my kids know the signs. 🎄

The second I start talking about fudge—gathering my ingredients, digging out that saucepan, and reaching for the parchment paper—they know: Christmas is close.

And with that realization comes the rule:

“DO NOT TOUCH THE FUDGE UNTIL CHRISTMAS EVE.”

(Do they listen? Absolutely not. Do I threaten to cancel Christmas? Only mildly. Do I hide the good batch? Every. Single. Year.)

The Fudge Recipe That’s Been Passed Down—And Still Slaps 👏

This is a no-fail, ten-minute fudge recipe that tastes like it took all day. It’s rich. It’s creamy. And it’s the definition of holiday joy in square form.

Ingredients:

3 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips 🍫 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk 🥛 1/4 cup butter 🧈 1 tsp vanilla extract 🍨 Optional: 1/2 cup chopped pecans or walnuts (Team Lots of Nuts over here, but you do you!) 🌰

How to Make It:

Line an 8×8 baking dish with parchment paper or foil and lightly spray it. In a saucepan (bonus points if it’s dented), combine chocolate chips, sweetened condensed milk, and butter over medium heat. Stir until everything is melted and smooth—this only takes about 5–7 minutes. Remove from heat and stir in vanilla. Add nuts if using. Pour into your prepared pan and smooth the top. Chill for at least 2 hours. Slice into squares. Hide your favorite pieces. Repeat next year.

The Fudge Rules (We Don’t Bend These) ✋

Rule #1: No one eats the fudge before Christmas Eve. Period.

Rule #2: Do not, I repeat, DO NOT cut into the center first. You eat from the edges like a civilized person.

Rule #3: You better double the batch, because someone is definitely sneaking pieces.

Rule #4: Don’t you dare “experiment” with peppermint extract or white chocolate. This is not the time.

Why It’s More Than Just Fudge

It’s the anticipation. The memories. The tradition of it all.

It’s standing at the stove thinking about my grandma in that avocado-green kitchen. It’s watching my kids sneak through the kitchen thinking they’re slick (they’re not). It’s tasting that first square and feeling like I’m 8 years old again, wearing itchy tights and waiting for Santa.

This fudge holds decades of holidays in every bite. 🎁

Fudge Is a Gift (Literally) 🎀

Need a last-minute homemade present that people will actually want? This fudge is your girl.

Wrap it in wax paper, drop it in a festive tin or mason jar, tie on a ribbon, and BOOM:

You just became the MVP of your family, your office, your mom group, or your gift exchange.

Who’s it great for?

Teachers 🍎 Neighbors 🏡 Your hairstylist 💇‍♀️ Your bestie who forgot to make cookies 🍪 YOU, babe. Keep a stash in the back of the fridge. You earned it.

Tips for Fudge Success (aka How Not to Mess It Up)

Use good chocolate. It makes a difference. Skip the bargain bin chips. Don’t overheat. Medium heat is plenty. Stir constantly and you’ll be golden. Score before cutting. If you want those clean, beautiful squares, let it chill and then slice with a hot knife. Keep it cold. Store it in the fridge and it’ll stay perfect for up to 2 weeks… if it lasts that long. Blast the Christmas tunes while you stir. Mariah Carey is optional, but encouraged.

The Real Secret Ingredient? Memory. 💛

Every year when I make this fudge, I feel like I’m stirring a little bit of the past into the present.

I think about my grandmother, that worn-out spoon, that dented pan, the laughter from the living room, the constant chaos of cooking- and all the food—and I smile.

Because for me, this fudge isn’t just a recipe. It’s a moment. It’s love. It’s tradition. And it’s my way of keeping Christmas connected across generations.

Final Thoughts from the Fudge-Obsessed Queen of Christmas 👑

The tree might not be decorated. The stockings might not match. There might still be glitter in your carpet from 2019.

But once the fudge is cooling, you can breathe easy.

It’s Christmas now.

So make a batch. Or two. Maybe three. Sneak a bite. Share a square.

Hide the rest.

And savor the kind of sweetness that only comes once a year.

Grab the full recipe here: Fudge Recipe – The Art of Connection

Tag me on Instagram [@thelastresortlakehouse] if you make it—I want to see your chocolatey squares, your vintage saucepans, and your cutest holiday memories.

And remember: if you cut into the middle piece first… I will know.